Shattered

After ten long years of fighting against Trump and everything he stands for, we have lost. Trump will become President of the United States. Again.

Did we somehow fail to make our case sufficiently? Or was too much of the country too walled off in their own dark fantasy to hear it? Either way, it no longer matters. Trump still won.

To have more than half the country elect a man who, as The New York Times said, is manifestly unfit for the office of President — it is nearly impossible for me to absorb and accept its implications. A convicted felon and fraud will now be running the country. David Frum, writing in The Atlantic, has made an excellent effort put it in perspective. Many others will surely follow.

“We must {now} learn to live in an America where an overwhelming number of our fellow citizens have chosen a president who holds the most fundamental values and traditions of our democracy, our Constitution, even our military in contempt.”

This is not an America that I recognize anymore.

This election was not a choice between two reasonable candidates who had differing policies and different visions for the future. It was a choice between a candidate who sought to protect our freedoms and our democracy and one that seeks to end them. Between one that values truth and compassion and one that revels in lies and grievance and revenge. Between a defender of our laws and one who has broken our laws — multiple times. Between a future where I could feel safe and secure that the Presidency is in competent hands and one where I fear the recklessness and chaos that lies ahead. And the voters looked at all of this —and chose Trump.

I am shattered.

The next four years will be exponentially worse than Trump’s first term…if only because he will be emboldened by the fact that the horribly vile and divisive campaign he ran actually got him back to the White House. And because he has learned that no matter what he does, no matter what laws or norms he breaks, he remains held unaccountable.

We can look forward to Trump carrying out many of the punitive and autocratic and destructive policies he promised. Things such as (to cite one recently quoted example) Robert F. Kennedy Jr. being in charge of the government’s health agencies. OMG! And, as a special bonus, Trump can now ensure that the Supreme Court remains with a conservative super-majority for at least a generation.

If we couldn’t prevent a Trump victory — despite all of our exhaustive efforts and despite all of the evidence of Trump’s “unfitness,” I don’t have much hope for anything changing any time soon. What can we do now that we haven’t already done — to no avail? If you’re waiting for the country to have a collective change of heart at some point — because they begin to see how bad a Trump second term will be — don’t count on it. Trump’s America is not an aberration; for now at least, it is who we are.

What is the proper response when you believe someone is a fascist and that person wins anyway? How do you continue to go about your normal business? How do you fight back? If you were living in Germany in the 1930’s, what would you have done to combat the rise of Hitler? Could you have done anything that would have altered the outcome? Almost certainly not. And how should that apply to what we do here now? I don’t have good answers to those questions. Certainly not any optimistic ones.

We are the victims of a political earthquake. Before we can move forward, we will need to pick up the pieces of the wreckage in front of us. It will take some time. Actually, the metaphor is imperfect. It’s worse than a  single earthquake. The political tremors of this election will continue to reverberate for the next four years — at least.

Many of you will look at the wreckage and have the motivation to rebuild — and eventually return to the fray: “Americans who care about democracy have work to do.” I applaud you and your resilience. I wish you success. Nothing would please me more than to see you succeed. And, at some level, I know it is the right thing to do. Giving up only further strengthens Trump.

Yet…others may decide that enough is enough and it’s time to move on to somewhere or something else — while we still can. Sadly, that’s the direction I am heading. I feel too old to want to spend my remaining years fighting…to preserve a country where a majority clearly have no interest in being “saved”…and for a cause that has so spectacularly failed to achieve its fundamental goal.

I am shattered. I am done.

Don’t say you weren’t warned

For my final post before Tuesday’s election, I turn over most of the space to two of my preferred publications: The New York Times and The Atlantic — with a listing of ultra-worthy articles published in the last couple of days.

I will spare you citations to articles that cover predictions as to who will win on Tuesday. We’ll know that soon enough (and I remain optimistic that Harris will prevail).

Rather, I focus here on a plethora of articles that assess the current state of our country as it sits on the verge of this most consequential of elections — with an emphasis on the unique dangers that Trump represents.

If this election were a jury trial, the case against Trump would be overwhelming. He’d be convicted on all counts. However, the final result is instead dependent on the court of public opinion — which has a different standard. If you are somehow still undecided here — and seek assistance in these last hours — read even a small selection of the following columns. The answers you seek will become very clear.

From The New York Times

There Will Always Be a Trump. That’s Only Part of the Problem:

“I’m writing those words in the context of a presidential contest that already represents a national failure. Even if Kamala Harris wins on Tuesday, there should be relief, not lasting joy. The United States will have come within an eyelash of electing a man who tried to overturn an election to cling to power.”

Donald Trump Is Done With Checks and Balances:

“Most Americans have lived only in a world where democracy was secure, where democracy was assumed. On Tuesday we’ll decide if we want to stay in that world or leave it behind.”

What I Truly Expect if an Unconstrained Trump Retakes Power

Let’s Not Blow It Again

All the Demons Are Here

I’ve Covered Authoritarians Abroad. Now I Fear One at Home

Will Democracy Ever Not Be on the Ballot?

There’s Something Very Different About Harris vs. Trump

and an Editorial Board statement that sums it all up:

You already know Donald Trump. He is unfit to lead. Watch him. Listen to those who know him best. He tried to subvert an election and remains a threat to democracy. He helped overturn Roe, with terrible consequences. Mr. Trump’s corruption and lawlessness go beyond elections: It’s his whole ethos. He lies without limit. If he’s re-elected, the G.O.P. won’t restrain him. Mr. Trump will use the government to go after opponents. He will pursue a cruel policy of mass deportations. He will wreak havoc on the poor, the middle class and employers. Another Trump term will damage the climate, shatter alliances and strengthen autocrats. Americans should demand better. Vote.

Of course, even if Harris wins on Tuesday, the battle will not be over. We will have have to contend with the inevitable Trump counter-attack: false claims of fraud and stolen elections, echoing what happened in 2020 — but with much greater preparation this time:

Trump, Preparing to Challenge the Results, Puts His 2020 Playbook Into Action

Monitors, Once Meant to Prevent Election Fraud, Now Seek to Prove It

The Army of Election Officials Ready to Reject the Vote

And from The Atlantic

No One Has an Alibi:

“Donald trump’s presidency was mitigated by his ignorance, idleness, and vanity. Trump did not know how the office worked. He did not invest any effort to learn. He wasted much of his time watching daytime television.

Defeat in 2020—and Trump’s plot to overturn that defeat—gave him a purpose: vengeance on those who bested him.

A second Trump presidency will have a much clearer agenda than the first. No more James Mattis to restrain him, no more John Kelly to chide him, no more Rex Tillerson to call him a ‘fucking moron.’ He will have only sycophants.”

Trump Needs Help

The Unique Danger of a Trumpist Oligarchy

and

How Republicans in Congress Could Try to Steal the Election

A personal postscript

I have claimed Trump is a fascist. I have said he is a threat to our democracy. Both are true.

But to clarify: When I say Trump is a fascist, I mean that, based on his past behavior and his own words during this campaign, I believe autocratic control is his goal. People like Putin are his idols; that’s who he aspires to be; a dictator. And I believe he will seriously attempt to achieve those goals. As The New York Times succinctly put it: When he says he will do things like prosecute his enemies and use soldiers against citizens, “Believe him.”

But do I believe he would end democracy within his first weeks of taking office? Of course not. Democracy will not instantly die if Trump wins. It will be more like a gradual erosion until the transition is at some point completed. So what about over the longer haul? Will Trump be successful in his autocratic aspirations before his term ends in four years? Perhaps. Perhaps not.

But that’s not the sole criteria by which we should judge the danger a Trump victory represents. Even if things never go quite that far, we are far from out of the woods.

What also matters is what Trump, explicitly or implicitly, will attempt to do. And how far he will actually succeed. And how much negative impact that will have on our daily lives. Do we really want a country where the survival of freedom and democracy requires a constant fight against the efforts of a President determined to undermine them? Where each dawn we awaken with a fear of what the coming hours will bring — with a President who will keep testing and retesting our willingness to tolerate his abuses? Is that what we want for our future — even if some form of democracy ultimately prevails? It is questions like these that most of the articles cited above (as well as my own prior posts here) attempt to address.

Whatever happens next is up to you, the voter. If the worst happens, don’t say you weren’t warned.